Frequently asked questions

Got questions? Here are answers to the most common queries about how the cross-cause fund works, how we make allocation decisions, and how to get involved.

The Cross-Cause Fund

How to give and who is the Cross-Cause Fund for.

How can I give to the CCF?

The Cross-Cause Fund is a real fund you can give to today. Donate here: Rethink Priorities Cross-Cause Fund.

What does the CCF give to?

The CCF gives to philanthropic funds focused on particular interventions or cause areas (e.g. The Lead Exposure Action Fund (LEAF) and the EA Animal Welfare Fund).

Is the CCF for large donors only?

No. The CCF welcomes donations of all sizes.

What are the core principles of the CCF?

Our approach rests on four pillars: continuously updating our model inputs and grant decisions using current information, expanding coverage to additional funds and cause areas, refining and improving our allocation methodology, and tracking and reporting impact to donors.

Cross-cause prioritization

Why comparing interventions across different cause areas matters, why it's difficult, and why we take a systematic approach.

Why do you think it is hard to be certain about where to give?

It's difficult to model reality empirically, and harder still to reach certainty on the philosophical questions involved, like how to weigh different types of outcomes, how to compare welfare across species, or how to handle uncertain long-term effects. These aren't questions with obvious answers, and reasonable people disagree. Our approach is to make these uncertainties explicit rather than paper over them with false confidence.

Which factors determine how I should allocate my giving?

People often think that the cost-effectiveness of work in each cause area is the main factor in deciding where to give.

But cost-effectiveness only gets us so far: how can we compare one intervention helping chickens to another helping people? We need to make subjective assumptions about the relative moral worths of chickens and humans.

Our analysis suggests that beliefs about animal moral weight, approaches to risk, and attitudes toward the cluelessness thesis are at least as important as cost-effectiveness in determining how we should allocate our giving.

The Cross-Cause Fund can combine empirical information (like cost-effectiveness) with normative information (which partly determines things like moral weights) to see how to allocate giving.

Why can’t I just identify the "best cause" and give everything there?

This approach has intuitive appeal but faces several problems. First, cost-effectiveness varies enormously within cause areas, a cause can score highly on scale, tractability, and neglectedness yet contain interventions ranging from highly effective to net-negative. Second, diminishing returns mean the best opportunity at $100,000 may not be the best at $500,000. Third, meeting the bar for confidently declaring one cause definitively "best" requires the same careful modeling we advocate, you can't escape the hard work through sweeping theoretical arguments. Learn more in our post on why and how to prioritize.

Why does CCF diversify so much?

To be clear, our uncertainty isn’t a pose. We have thoroughly researched the topic and think the case for our approach is strong, given the information we have. We think these questions are hard enough that strong confidence in any single cause is difficult to justify.

Is "Common Sense" enough to decide where to give?

"Common sense" is excellent for identifying that global poverty is bad or that animal torture is wrong, but it fails completely at making trade-offs. Common sense may not tell you how many resources to shift from malaria prevention to pandemic preparedness. And if one specific tradeoff may seem “commonsensical” (e.g., almost always prioritizing humans over animals), this may be an indication of a bias more than of what is fair. To the extent that we still want to put weight on “common sense”, we should also seriously consider more reflected alternatives—e.g., by entertaining various worldviews, as we do to get our CCF allocation.

Is there rigorous research comparing interventions across different cause areas?

Very little. Most effective altruism prioritization research focuses on comparisons within causes rather than across them. GiveWell provides rigorous cost-effectiveness estimates for global health charities, but there's no equivalent that systematically compares global health interventions to animal welfare or catastrophic risk interventions. In practice, many allocation decisions across causes are made on a surprisingly unsystematic basis, which is part of why we built our cross-cause model. Learn more in our post on why and how to prioritize.

Why bother putting numbers on things that are inherently uncertain?

Quantifying beliefs, even when highly uncertain, prevents "vague thinking." For example, there is a massive mathematical difference between a 1% and a 0.001% chance of success in a cause like wild animal welfare. Until we put a number on it, we don't truly know what we believe or what the implications of those beliefs are. Prior research shows that this discipline significantly improves the accuracy of thinking compared to purely qualitative "gut feelings." Learn more about benefits of modeling.

Should I give now or wait?

There's no single answer: it depends on your expected returns, on the giving opportunities available, and if you expect there is a critical period for a particular intervention.

We think it is plausible that artificial intelligence may reach a transformative level within the coming decade. This may lead to: (i) new funding opportunities, (ii) large investment returns, (iii) lock-in of current values, (iv) bottlenecking of progress in critical areas, (v) risk of existential loss. Effects of (i) and (ii) may be sufficiently large that risk-neutral individuals should consider saving a decent proportion of their portfolio.

Saving to give later can be risky. Markets can crash, transformative investments returns may be expropriated, your motivation may drift, and if many donors save, each future dollar may do less good as it is crowded out. Read our recent article on the topic here.

As a rough rule of thumb:

  • Aim to give at least 2-8% over the entire period before TAI
  • Give more now if you are concerned about AI Safety
  • Give more now if you think TAI is not likely in the next decade
  • Plan for back-loaded donation schedule, adjusting donations upwards if AGI does not arrive

Cross-cause model

How our allocation model works, what uncertainties it accounts for, and where its limitations lie.

What is the difference between the CCF, the Cross-Cause Model and the Donor Compass?

The Cross-Cause Fund (CCF) is a philanthropic fund that pools donors’ money and allocates it between different cause areas.

The CCF’s allocations are determined by a mathematical model, the Cross-Cause Model. The model combines data on the recipient funds with carefully-researched assumptions about how to compare different types of benefits. Read more on our Methodology page.

The Donor Compass is a simplified interface to access a version of the Cross-Cause Model which anyone can run with their own assumptions.

Do I need to understand the model to engage with the CCF?

No. The CCF and the Cross-Cause Model are maintained by a team of experts at Rethink Priorities, so donors don’t have to do anything.

For donors who want to see how the model works, our public Methodology provides detailed information.

Why use explicit modeling instead of intuition?

Deciding how to allocate resources based on high-level characteristics of causes is likely to mislead. Cause prioritization involves many interacting complexities: cost-effectiveness across different funding levels, how to compare very different outcomes (saving a life vs. increasing income, helping humans vs. helping animals), and how to weigh high-probability, modest impact against low-probability, large impact. Holding all of this in your head isn't plausible. Explicit models can't capture everything, but they are an essential input for decision-making when allocating across or within areas. Importantly, implicit models are less transparent–obscuring weaknesses–and have less capacity to account for the large number of complex, interacting considerations that high-stakes resource allocation decisions involve. Learn more about benefits of modeling.

What are the inputs that determine the CCF’s allocations and who determines them?

First, we have estimated the cost-effectiveness of each fund considered according to the relevant metrics, how it is affected by transformative AI development, and the severity of its diminishing returns. In the Cross-Cause Model, these inputs are fixed and worldview-independent.

Then come worldviews, bundles of best guesses about other relevant parameters such as moral weights (how to convert the different metrics into a single one), how to deal with risk, and degree of cluelessness about whether the far future effects of our actions are even good. Each worldview is assigned a credence.

Finally, we aggregate across the weighted worldviews to get a final allocation. This is done by assigning credences to different aggregation methods, and allocating based on the weighted average.

For the CCF, the worldview and aggregation methods inputs have been determined by our team, based on research and expert consultation, just like for the worldview-independent parameters. Donor Compass users can give alternative inputs and see how this would change the recommended allocation.

More details here.

Doesn’t modeling just allow you to "fudge" the numbers to get the result you want?

Actually, it's the opposite. Qualitative reasoning makes it very easy to subconsciously adjust your logic to reach a preferred conclusion. An explicit model is disciplined; once the numbers and formulas are set, you have to follow where they lead. This makes it much harder to "hide" biases and much easier for others to point out exactly where they think a calculation is wrong. Read more about benefits of modeling.

Does the "precision" of a model’s numbers provide a false sense of security?

It can. A model that ends in one specific allocation can look more certain than it is, and nobody should read ours as “we know the right split to the nearest percent.” Many nearby allocations are probably just as defensible given what we know. We still publish a single allocation because a fund has to decide where each dollar goes. An allocation given as a range would be more candid about our uncertainty, but a range can’t tell anyone how to split a donation.

That said, we do take care to avoid being overconfident:

  • We don’t bet on one set of assumptions. The model includes several worldviews that disagree about things like animal moral weight and attitudes to risk. Each one gets a say in the allocation in proportion to the weight we give it, so the result isn’t simply the best guess of whichever worldview we find most plausible.
  • We take the disagreement seriously when combining worldviews. There is no uniquely correct way to do this, so we document the method we use and why.
  • We check how much the answer depends on our assumptions. Sensitivity analyses show which assumptions move the allocation most, so we know where our precision is weakest and where more research is most valuable.
  • We publish our assumptions and keep updating them. The allocation will move as the evidence and our methods improve.

Treat the allocation as our best current answer under uncertainty, not as a measurement. If you disagree with our worldviews, our Donor Compass tool lets you run the model with your own assumptions.

Read In defence of modeling to learn more.

What are the main limitations of the model?

Key limitations include:

  • Dependence on fund inputs: The model relies on information from funds themselves, which may change as their plans evolve.
  • Simplified diminishing returns: The model doesn't distinguish between interventions that decline in effectiveness because they might backfire versus those where success probability decreases.
  • Difficulty modeling far-future impact: Assessing long-term or extinction risk reduction is inherently uncertain, and input choices can significantly swing GCR allocations.
  • Sensitivity to animal welfare parameters: Small changes in moral weights for invertebrates can substantially shift the animal welfare allocation due to the large numbers involved.
  • Limited modeling of interaction effects: The model doesn't fully capture how donors, grantmakers, and grant recipients influence each other's impact.

What does the model exclude?

The model doesn't currently cover all interventions or inputs we consider relevant. On the intervention side, we hope to include political giving to democracy preservation later this year, but it's not yet incorporated. Giving to political candidates is excluded entirely, as a 501(c)(3), Rethink Priorities is legally prohibited from supporting or opposing candidates or parties, including any advice that could be construed as favoring a particular candidate. The model also doesn't cover "meta" causes aimed at improving giving decisions or expanding the number of people working on priority causes. On the philosophical and empirical side, several inputs aren't yet incorporated: the model doesn't account for virtue ethics, flow-through effects (the indirect or downstream impacts of interventions), or interaction effects between donors, grantmakers, and grant recipients. Most inputs currently use point estimates rather than full probability distributions. We're prioritizing the addition of flow-through effects and distributions later this year, and we plan to expand the model's coverage more broadly as our research develops.

Is this a final version of the cross-cause model?

No. Our cross-cause model is a living tool. While it represents our best current methodology, it doesn't yet capture every factor relevant to estimating impact. For example, we're not currently modeling certain interventions, such as alternative proteins, which we intend to add.

What types of uncertainty does the Cross-Cause Model account for?

We explicitly model four types of uncertainty:

How do models handle "diminishing returns" differently than intuition?

Intuition often fails to account for how the 100th million dollar does less good than the 1st million. Our model allows us to test specific mathematical curves, like logarithmic diminishing returns, to see exactly where cost-effectiveness might drop (e.g., a 100x drop after $100M). This level of precision is impossible to hold in your head while simultaneously weighing other factors like moral weights or success probabilities. Learn more about benefits of modeling.

How does the model handle situations where different moral theories completely disagree?

Because different ethical worldviews (like Utilitarianism vs. Deontology) often disagree on how to measure "good," we use a "weighted average" of several aggregation methods. Rather than picking one "favorite" theory or a simple majority vote, which can lead to "fanaticism" where one extreme view hijacks the budget, we prioritize Bargaining Methods (like Nash Bargaining). This approach treats different moral theories like delegates in a "moral parliament" who must negotiate a fair split of resources. By weighting these different methods, we ensure the fund's allocations remain stable, ethically humble, and resistant to any single philosophical outlier. Learn more about aggregation methods.

How do you handle the fact that most philosophical theories might eventually be proven wrong?

We embrace a default attitude of intellectual skepticism. Unlike science, philosophical "experiments" cannot be verified in a lab, and historically, many philosophical positions have eventually been revised or discarded. Because of this, we avoid "betting the farm" on any single contentious claim about the far future or specific decision theories. Our fund management strategy is designed to accept uncertainty. We provide a diversified portfolio that achieves high impact under many different plausible versions of the truth, rather than chasing a single, fragile "optimum" that might rely on a flawed assumption. Learn more on why we should be uncertain about cause prioritization.

Is the cost of building these complex models actually worth it?

When allocating hundreds of millions of dollars, the "Value of Information" is extremely high. Even a 0.001% improvement in how effectively that money is spent could justify a million-dollar investment in modeling. Given that different causes can vary in effectiveness by orders of magnitude, the risk of not modeling is far more expensive than the research required to build the model. Read In defence of modelling to learn more.

How will you prioritize model improvements?

The pace and depth of refinement will scale with the fund's size. As donation volume increases, the value of marginal improvements grows correspondingly. We'll invest in model development in proportion to the resources we steward. If you're interested in supporting this work, contact us at fund@rethinkpriorities.org.

Managing the CCF

How we manage the Cross-Cause Fund to ensure donations are allocated effectively and transparently.

Does Rethink Priorities charge any fees for managing the Cross-Cause Fund?

No. Rethink Priorities does not charge any management fees. 100% of your donation is directed to the recommended grantees.

When will my donation be disbursed to the recipient funds?

We aim to disburse donations quickly when we're confident that recipient funds can deploy them to high-impact opportunities. When a fund has strong near-term grantmaking opportunities with reasonably well-characterized cost-effectiveness, we aim to disburse within eight weeks of receiving your donation.

We don’t disburse everything within that timeframe. For some funds, the recommended allocation could be several times their current budget, which is more than they could deploy within a few months. Holding back a portion lets us base later disbursements on the opportunities that actually come up rather than on spending projections alone. Next to that, we keep developing and improving the model behind the CCF so in some cases it might be preferable to wait a bit longer and disburse after the model update.

We report on disbursement timing and rationale so you can see how pooled funds have been allocated. If you’d like your contribution deployed within a specific window, contact us at fund@rethinkpriorities.org to discuss options.

How do we know what our grantees will do with the money?

We recognize that past performance doesn't guarantee future results. We continuously monitor grantmaker behavior, and if a fund's allocation decisions or organizational conduct diverge from our expectations, or if relevant experts raise concerns, we will reassess our recommendation and, if necessary, adjust the allocation or remove the fund from our portfolio.

Does Rethink Priorities have conflicts of interest?

RP has received grants from Longview Philanthropy, EA Animal Welfare Fund, Navigation Fund, and Coefficient Giving. RP has done commissioned research for GiveWell and Coefficient Giving. In addition, one RP staff member serves as an advisor to the EA Animal Welfare Fund but is recused from grantmaking decisions involving RP. RP is not involved in any grant-making decisions of these organizations, and RP carries out independent cost-effectiveness analyses of any funds we decide to include in our Cross-Cause Fund.

What cause areas and funds do you plan to add?

We're actively working to expand the Cross-Cause Fund's coverage. We're exploring democracy protection (non-partisan) and climate change over the next few months. Longer term, we're considering areas such as digital minds and AI welfare, economic growth interventions, wild animal welfare, additional biosecurity interventions, and "meta" causes aimed at increasing resources flowing to high-impact charities. We'll communicate any additions through regular updates. For a full list of funds we intend to vet for inclusion, see the Methodology section.

Will I see the impact of my personal donations?

For RP Cross-Cause DAF donors, we'll aim to provide a personal dashboard that shows the estimated impact attributable to your contributions. For the RP Cross-Cause Fund, we'll publish aggregated impact reporting for the fund as a whole.

How will you track grant activity?

For donors in the RP Cross-Cause DAF, your personal account will automatically track: when the DAF receives funds, when funds are sent to grant recipients, when funds reach recipients' bank accounts, and overall transaction activity (anonymous by default).

What will you report publicly?

We'll make as much information as possible public, including: annual reports summarizing impact and spending, cost-effectiveness estimates for grants made (with transparent methodology), clear benchmarks for success and failure (with public acknowledgment of any mistakes), and a grant pipeline showing recently completed grants, current grants, and forthcoming recommendations.

How will you estimate impact?

We've built internal models to estimate the cost per unit of impact for major activities supported by each fund. We'll use these to estimate the impact achieved with granted resources. We recognize this approach has limitations. Not all activities will be captured, and impact tracking is more straightforward for some areas (like global health) than others. We're committed to improving our methods over time.

Recommended allocations

Common questions about our recommended allocation, how we arrived at it, and what it does and doesn't account for.

Why does animal welfare get so much?

Animal welfare receives a relatively large share in the CCF split. This is an output of the model. There are several factors that cause the model to allocate a large share to animal welfare, which are explained below. This might change in the future, as we keep updating and improving the model.

Three things push the model towards animal welfare:

  • Scale. Most of the individuals who can plausibly suffer are non-human animals. The worldviews we consider differ a lot on how much each animal matters, but many give animals substantial moral weight.
  • Cost-effectiveness. Some animal welfare interventions help very large numbers of animals for a low cost per animal.
  • Robustness. Compared with work on global catastrophic risks, the effects of these interventions are easier to observe and depend less on long chains of speculative assumptions.

Three things stop it from taking everything:

  • Future people count too. Reducing global catastrophic risks could benefit a vast number of future people, so worldviews that give weight to the long-term future value that work highly.
  • We still take seriously the possibility that animals matter far less than humans.
  • Funds can only use so much money well. Global health and development funds can absorb more funding at high cost-effectiveness than animal welfare funds. Once the best animal welfare opportunities are funded, additional dollars are better spent elsewhere.

If you think animals matter more or less than we do, the Donor Compass lets you see how much that changes the allocation [link]. Our assumptions about animal moral weights are in our house views on the Methodology page.

Why isn’t 100% of the fund allocated to AI risk if the potential scale is so high?

While the potential scale of AI disruption is massive, "Scale" is only one of many factors. Using scale alone ignores:

  • Probability of Success: Many AI interventions are highly speculative.
  • Immediacy: Programs like GiveDirectly or Against Malaria Foundation help real people today. Even if AI transforms the world in 10 years, it doesn't solve the suffering occurring right now.
  • Risk Aversion: A pure "Expected Value" play might suggest going all-in on AI, but even a small amount of risk aversion or "cluelessness" about the far future suggests a more diversified portfolio is more rational.

Learn more on how cause prioritization can go wrong.

Why not give each cause a fixed share of my donations?

You might think that rather than using a model, Rethink Priorities should simply publish a fixed “ideal split” between cause areas.

But it’s not that simple. Because the best opportunities get funded first, the ideal split depends on how much money you are giving: you might spend your first dollar and your thousandth dollar in the same way; by the time you reach your billionth philanthropic dollar, you will have saturated the best recipient funds. That will change how you should split the money.

When you contribute to the CCF, your gift forms part of a “megadonor” that considers these macro factors.

Will the allocation change in the future?

The CCF’s allocations will change as we make improvements, and as the world changes.

Our M&E team is constantly updating information about recipient funds, which improves our cost-effectiveness estimates. They are also bringing more funds - working in additional cause areas - into the Cross-Cause Model.

Our researchers are constantly updating and improving the model itself. We will also periodically update the “house views” that determine how we evaluate/adjust different types of estimated benefits, and involve experts to give their views.

This means that the way the CCF allocates money between funds will continue to evolve over time.

Has your allocation recently changed?

We’re continuously updating, improving, and incorporating new information into our cross-cause model. Check this latest updates and improvements doc for more information.

How do you keep your allocation decisions up to date?

We maintain ongoing communication with each fund we support to gather updated data on: diminishing returns (how marginal effectiveness changes with recent grantmaking), intervention mix (what types of interventions they're funding), and the funder landscape (other funders in their space and how this affects strategy). We've established relationships with all currently included funds, and each has indicated a willingness to share this information.

How sensitive are these results to changes in your inputs?

We’re preparing a detailed sensitivity analysis that explores how different answers affect the recommended allocations. Check back soon.

How can I ask questions
or provide feedback?

Contact us at fund@rethinkpriorities.org . We welcome scrutiny and are committed to continuous improvement.